When Compact Discs Ruled The Roost
At the turn of the millennium, the global music business stood atop a glistening, seemingly impregnable fortress. In 1999, US recorded music revenues reached an all-time high of $14.6 billion, propelled almost entirely by the compact disc - a format so lucrative that labels shipped 942.5 million CDs in the year 2000 alone. Executives viewed their business through the lens of that shiny polycarbonate wrapper. If you wanted the hit single, you bought the plastic disc, priced at $18 for twelve tracks, whether you wanted the other eleven or not. It was one of the greatest bundling monopolies in modern consumer history, and the incumbents assumed the wrapper itself was the product.
Within fifteen years, that fortress lay in ruins. Peer-to-peer networks like Napster and LimeWire unbundled the album overnight, while Apple’s iTunes fractured pricing into $0.99 downloads. By 2014, total US recorded music revenues had plunged 54.1% to a trough of $6.7 billion. Crucially, the industry didn't collapse because people stopped listening to music; it collapsed because incumbents mistook a wrapper and distribution revolution for a passing regulatory and piracy nuisance. Labels spent a decade suing teenagers and slapping restrictive digital rights management onto files instead of reimagining how music was delivered. Only when Spotify and Apple Music replaced asset ownership with frictionless, continuous access did the industry roar back - surpassing its 1999 peak to reach $17.7 billion in the US and over $31.7 billion globally across 837 million paid subscribers.
History rarely repeats itself verbatim, yet its structural rhymes are unmistakable. Today, the global asset management industry is standing in its own 1999 moment - celebrating record product proliferation while overlooking the technological tide quietly eroding the foundations of its favourite wrapper.
The Second Wave: When Creation Costs Hit Zero
To understand where asset management is heading, look at the second, far faster disruption hitting the music industry right now: generative AI. Having survived the distribution shock of streaming, record labels are confronting a supply-side tsunami. According to streaming platform Deezer’s 2026 disclosures, 44% of all newly uploaded tracks - roughly 75,000 songs every single day, or more than two million a month - are now 100% AI-generated via platforms like Suno and Udio. Over a twelve-month stretch, Spotify had to purge more than 75 million spam and AI-slop tracks just to keep its catalogue navigable. Yet despite accounting for nearly half of all new supply, those AI tracks capture only 1% to 3% of genuine human streams - and Deezer flagged up to 85% of their plays as bot-driven fraud engineered to siphon royalties out of the payout pool.
The strategic lesson for incumbents is brutal and clear: when the marginal cost of creating a product drops toward zero, proliferation explodes, noise drowns out signal, and economic value migrates entirely from the static product to curation, provenance, and programmable pipes. Major labels spent 2024 suing AI startups for copyright infringement; by late 2025 and 2026, Warner Music Group and Universal Music Group had pivoted to landmark licensing deals, realizing you cannot litigate away a superior architecture. In a world of infinite supply, owning the wrapper means nothing; controlling the intelligence layer that curates and personalizes the stream means everything.
Wall Street’s "1,300 CD Editions" Moment
Now turn your gaze from Abbey Road to Wall Street and the City of London. In 2025, US ETF launches shattered every historical benchmark, with over 1,330 new funds hitting exchanges in a single calendar year. That breakneck pace has only accelerated through 2026, with more than 1,250 launches through the third quarter alone, 74% of them actively managed. Global ETF inflows have surged past $1.5 trillion annually, and issuers are popping champagne corks. Yet beneath the headline triumph lies a telling symptom: fund closures are accelerating rapidly (127 in 2025, and 159 through Q3 2026), heavily concentrated in hyper-niche, single stock leveraged, and micro-thematic funds that fail to gather sustainable assets. Wall Street is inadvertently recreating the music industry’s Spotify slop problem.
In the early 2000s, record labels tried to save the CD by releasing deluxe editions, dual-discs, and copy-protected variants - desperate permutations of a 1980s physical format right before streaming made the disc redundant for mass distribution. Today’s explosion of 1,300+ annual ETF launches looks remarkably similar. For all its undeniable tax efficiency and intraday liquidity, the ETF is a 1993 wrapper engineered around legacy market plumbing: T+1 settlement cycles, Authorized Participants, transfer agents, custodial chains, and rigid exchange trading hours. Every time an asset manager wants to offer a slight variation - a 2x single-stock bet, a 10% downside buffer, or a regional factor tilt - it must mint, list, seed, and market another standalone ticker.
We are stretching a thirty-year-old wrapper to its absolute structural limit. And for financial advisers and discretionary fund managers, that proliferation is creating an acute implementation bottleneck: thousands of overlapping tickers that look like choice on a factsheet yet leave portfolios exposed to hidden concentration and operational drag.
The Tokenization Inflection Point
For years, wealth managers dismissed fund tokenization as a perennial five years away science project - interesting at fintech conferences, irrelevant to Monday morning’s investment committee. In 2026, that timeline collapsed.
Following the UK Financial Conduct Authority’s landmark consultation paper on fund tokenization this spring - alongside parallel regulatory green lights across the EU, Singapore, and the US - native on-chain fund registers have moved from whitepapers into institutional production. When BlackRock rolled out tokenized UCITS Money Market Fund share classes across Europe and the UK in August, bringing 24/7 peer-to-peer transferability and near-instant on-chain settlement to institutional liquidity, the starting gun officially fired.
This forces an uncomfortable question for every fund selector, DFM, and wealth manager: If ETFs were the iTunes and Spotify upgrade over legacy mutual funds, is on-chain tokenization the AI-native leap that renders thousands of redundant tickers obsolete?
Consider the mechanics. Why launch 1,300 separate ETFs to approximate bespoke exposures when tokenization turns a portfolio into programmable software? Instead of forcing advisers and clients to buy pre-packaged, one-size-fits-all albums - rigid model portfolios stitched together from dozens of overlapping tickers and rebalanced on sluggish quarterly cycles - tokenized architecture allows AI portfolio engines to assemble, rebalance, and settle personalized, atomic exposures 24/7. Fractional precision, automated tax-loss harvesting, and client-specific ethical or factor constraints can be executed directly at the account level with zero transfer-agent friction.
What Survives the Flood?
Does this mean the ETF disappears overnight? Not at all. Look back at the music industry’s most surprising postscript: even as streaming conquered 84% of US music revenue, vinyl staged an eighteen-year consecutive comeback, generating $1.4 billion in annual sales and outselling CDs in unit volume. Physical media didn't vanish; it bifurcated into a high-conviction, tactile niche for collectors and purists, while daily mass consumption moved to frictionless, algorithmic digital rails.
The exact same bifurcation awaits investment wrappers. Flagship, ultra-liquid benchmark ETFs - the Dark Side of the Moon or Thriller of core equity and sovereign debt beta will remain institutional bedrock for decades. They are the vinyl of modern portfolios: deep, trusted, transparent, and practically indestructible.
It is the sprawling middle, the thousands of me-too thematic, single-stock, and incrementally tweaked active ETFs, that sits directly in the blast radius. When AI-driven portfolio construction meets 24/7 tokenized rails, the competitive advantage shifts decisively away from who can launch the most tickers and toward who controls the intelligent architecture that personalizes outcomes for the end investor.
In 1999, nobody inside a major record label believed an invisible digital stream could dismantle a $14.6 billion physical empire within a decade. Twelve months ago, few on Wall Street or in the City believed programmable, tokenized portfolios could challenge the ETF wrapper’s golden age on a timescale measured in years rather than decades.
The music is already changing. The only question for portfolio architects is whether they are still pressing CDs - or building the streaming engine.
Irene Bauer